Ordering takeout was easy as pie (ha). Pizza was still hot upon pickup and was a great air freshener for my car. The Big Wick is loaded with toppings, the 12” was perfect for two very hungry people.
Eric Nygaard
-
January 31, 2026
Very good food. I had Calzone. Our party also had pizza and wickadilla. We shared everything along with order of breadsticks. Great tasting sauce. Fresh toppings on everything. Staff paid great attention to us. Always asking if we needed refills before glass was empty. Will definitely stop here first next time in town. I wish I would have taken pictures when our food first got here. This is all that was left.
LISA C.
-
January 03, 2026
I'm still giving today a 4 even though I wasn't completely satisfied. I've been here before, several times thinking it's at the top of the list for good pizza; I wanted pizza but not a lot so I was happy to hear they had a lunch special for $9.99. The server said It was an 8 inch that came with 4 toppings so I order pepperoni, sausage, beef and onion with a half chicken salad. I regretted not ordering light sauce but because the pizza was small I didn't think I had to; the sauce was sweet and a little heavy, I couldn't taste the beef at all, my salad was good; for a half it's such a generous portion; I was surprised when the receipt came with charges for toppings, the server then says it's $9.99 for a cheese pizza, toppings are extra; I told her I didn't know that; I tipped her because she served me but the better the service the better the tip; she asked me how I was doing way after she brought me my receipt, neverto ask how the food was nor if I wanted dessert or anything else during my time. I was really surprised as they weren't busy, only one other table besides me that another server serviced.
Abigail Milam
-
November 18, 2025
This is genuinely the greatest pizza I have ever had. I wasn’t a big pizza fan until I had this pizza, and now I order Wick’s once a week. The dough-sauce-cheese ratio is phenomenal. The crust is crispy on the outside but doughy and soft on the inside. Cheese is perfectly melty and makes for a good cheese pull. It also has a genuine mozzarella flavor. The sauce is sweet, but not too sweet. It is truly the perfect pizza and I’m satisfied each time I eat it!
Ed Hardy
-
September 03, 2024
I recently visited Wicks Pizza and was absolutely blown away by both the food and the service! Let me start with the pizza—WOW. The crust was perfectly crispy, the sauce was rich and flavorful, and the toppings were fresh and generously portioned. I opted for their pepperoni, (for the kids pleasure) Before and it was hands down one of the best pizzas I’ve ever had. Every bite was a delight, with just the right balance of flavors and textures.
But what really made my experience stand out was the customer service. There was a small mix-up with my order, and I received the wrong pizza. I was initially a bit disappointed, but when I brought it to the attention of the staff, they handled it with such professionalism and care. They quickly apologized and offered to remake my order right away, even throwing in a small discount for the inconvenience without me even asking. The staff was genuinely friendly and attentive, making sure I was comfortable and satisfied while I waited. Our server stayed on top of the drinks and checked in frequently enough to not be annoying or leaving us underserved.
When the correct pizza arrived, it was piping hot and absolutely delicious, worth every minute of the wait. Mistakes happen, but the way Wicks Pizza turned the situation around was impressive. They truly care about their customers and go the extra mile to ensure a great experience. I’ll definitely be coming back for more, and I highly recommend Wicks Pizza to anyone who loves great food and outstanding service! Definitely 5 stars and much appreciated.
Our Address
975 Baxter Ave, Louisville, KY 40204, USA
Claim Listing: Wick’s Pizza Parlor
Please Login or Register an Account to Claim Listing
Ordering takeout was easy as pie (ha). Pizza was still hot upon pickup and was a great air freshener for my car. The Big Wick is loaded with toppings, the 12” was perfect for two very hungry people.
Very good food. I had Calzone. Our party also had pizza and wickadilla. We shared everything along with order of breadsticks. Great tasting sauce. Fresh toppings on everything. Staff paid great attention to us. Always asking if we needed refills before glass was empty. Will definitely stop here first next time in town. I wish I would have taken pictures when our food first got here. This is all that was left.
I'm still giving today a 4 even though I wasn't completely satisfied. I've been here before, several times thinking it's at the top of the list for good pizza; I wanted pizza but not a lot so I was happy to hear they had a lunch special for $9.99. The server said It was an 8 inch that came with 4 toppings so I order pepperoni, sausage, beef and onion with a half chicken salad. I regretted not ordering light sauce but because the pizza was small I didn't think I had to; the sauce was sweet and a little heavy, I couldn't taste the beef at all, my salad was good; for a half it's such a generous portion; I was surprised when the receipt came with charges for toppings, the server then says it's $9.99 for a cheese pizza, toppings are extra; I told her I didn't know that; I tipped her because she served me but the better the service the better the tip; she asked me how I was doing way after she brought me my receipt, neverto ask how the food was nor if I wanted dessert or anything else during my time. I was really surprised as they weren't busy, only one other table besides me that another server serviced.
This is genuinely the greatest pizza I have ever had. I wasn’t a big pizza fan until I had this pizza, and now I order Wick’s once a week. The dough-sauce-cheese ratio is phenomenal. The crust is crispy on the outside but doughy and soft on the inside. Cheese is perfectly melty and makes for a good cheese pull. It also has a genuine mozzarella flavor. The sauce is sweet, but not too sweet. It is truly the perfect pizza and I’m satisfied each time I eat it!
I recently visited Wicks Pizza and was absolutely blown away by both the food and the service! Let me start with the pizza—WOW. The crust was perfectly crispy, the sauce was rich and flavorful, and the toppings were fresh and generously portioned. I opted for their pepperoni, (for the kids pleasure) Before and it was hands down one of the best pizzas I’ve ever had. Every bite was a delight, with just the right balance of flavors and textures. But what really made my experience stand out was the customer service. There was a small mix-up with my order, and I received the wrong pizza. I was initially a bit disappointed, but when I brought it to the attention of the staff, they handled it with such professionalism and care. They quickly apologized and offered to remake my order right away, even throwing in a small discount for the inconvenience without me even asking. The staff was genuinely friendly and attentive, making sure I was comfortable and satisfied while I waited. Our server stayed on top of the drinks and checked in frequently enough to not be annoying or leaving us underserved. When the correct pizza arrived, it was piping hot and absolutely delicious, worth every minute of the wait. Mistakes happen, but the way Wicks Pizza turned the situation around was impressive. They truly care about their customers and go the extra mile to ensure a great experience. I’ll definitely be coming back for more, and I highly recommend Wicks Pizza to anyone who loves great food and outstanding service! Definitely 5 stars and much appreciated.